Skip to content

November 2026
The Difference


Table of Contents

The Doctors Company, the nation’s largest physician-owned medical malpractice insurer, announced that it has completed the acquisition of ProAssurance, a specialty insurer with broad expertise in medical liability, products liability for medical technology and life sciences companies, and workers’ compensation insurance.
Read more.

About Our Issue

Medical professional liability insurance is a complex business, and many of its most important concepts are easily confused for those with less experience navigating the industry. Shared or separate limits? Occurrence or claims-made? Admitted or non-admitted? Does your policy require nose or tail coverage? Explaining these differences is a key skill when working with the physicians, practices, and healthcare organizations you serve—or bringing new talent into your agency and the MPL industry.

That is why we created our “The Difference” article series. We received several requests for educational content that broke down commonly misunderstood insurance terms in clear, practical language. The initial release was a hit which spawned a variety of requests from agencies, medical societies, and others to cover additional topics.

Now, five years in, we have curated what just may be the ultimate “The Difference” collection. This issue brings together every article we have ever published in the ProVisions series, plus several which are new to our publication, to create a single, comprehensive reference you can keep at your fingertips.

WebBannersNov26-01

Shared Limits vs. Separate Limits

Insurance policies with multiple insureds sometimes offer the policyholder the option of shared limits or separate limits. The difference between these options dictates how the coverage limits of the policy are available to its individual insureds.

Separate Limits: The entity, each insured, or both have coverage up to the full limits of the policy.

For example, on a surgical center’s policy with a $1 million per claim limit, if the surgical center, one of its surgeons, and one of its anesthesiologists are named in a claim, each would have their own $1 million coverage limit for the claim.

Shared Limits: A single limit covers the organization and the individual insureds on the policy.

In the example above on a shared limit policy, the surgical center, surgeon, and anesthesiologist are covered by and share in the same $1 million limit.

For physician insureds—whether in group or solo practice—it’s important to note that hospitals may require separate limits and specific liability levels for physicians maintaining admitting privileges. Likewise, states may have their own requirements on limits or prohibitions against shared or separate limits in certain scenarios. Pennsylvania, for example, does not allow shared corporate limits. In states that have no prohibition against it, it is quite common for corporations to not obtain separate limits, but instead to share in the limits of their insured physicians.

ScottSpinolawTITLEupdate

 

WebBannersNov26-03

Incident vs. Aggregate Policy Limits

Policy limits are the maximum amounts an insurance company will pay out for claims. These limits fall into two categories:

  • Incident Limit: The maximum amount payable for a single covered incident.
  • Aggregate Limit: The maximum amount payable for all covered claims during the policy period.

Incident Limits

Incident limits, also known as per-occurrence limits, refer to the maximum amount an insurer will pay for a single claim or incident. This limit applies to each individual event or occurrence that triggers a claim regardless of how many claims are made during the policy period (subject to not exceeding the aggregate limit). For example, with a $1 million occurrence limit, the insurer will cover up to $1 million for each individual claim.

Key aspects of incident limits include:

  • Renewal: The occurrence limit resets with each policy period, allowing for payment for new covered claims up to the limit for each incident within the term.
  • Coverage Specificity: Not all incidents are covered, so it’s important to review the policy details to ensure it covers the types of events an insured might face.
  • Premiums: Policies with higher incident limits generally cost more. Balancing the cost with the necessary coverage level is crucial.

Incident limits are detailed in the policy and provide clear coverage amounts for each claim. Some policies may also have sub-limits for specific types of damages. Deductibles, co-insurance, and other policy features can affect the total payout. For instance, a $10,000 deductible is paid by the policyholder and would reduce the insurer’s payout by that amount for each claim.

Incident limits provide straightforward coverage for each event. They are generally easy to understand, as they cover single events. Insureds are limited to the coverage amount for each incident, however, without the broader coverage options available with aggregate limits. If a single claim exceeds the incident limit, the policyholder will have to cover the excess cost.

Aggregate Limits

An aggregate limit is the maximum amount an insurer will pay for all covered claims during a policy period. Unlike an occurrence limit, which caps the payout for a single claim, the aggregate limit covers the total payout for all covered claims combined.

Key aspects of aggregate limits include:

  • Coverage Caps: The aggregate limit caps the total amount the insurer will pay for multiple claims within a policy period. For example, if the limit is $1 million and multiple claims of $500,000 each are made, the insurer will pay up to the $1 million limit.
  • Policy Variations: Aggregate limits vary by policy and insurer—some insurance policies may have lower limits than others. Higher-risk entities may have lower aggregate limits due to increased risk.
  • Business Impact: Aggregate limits are particularly significant for practices with multiple potential claims. Knowing the limit helps in managing risk and ensuring adequate coverage.
  • Combination: Most policies include both an aggregate limit and a per-incident limit, where the per-incident limit applies to each claim, and the aggregate limit applies to the total payout for all claims during the policy period.

The aggregate limit is often a multiple of the per-incident limit. For example, a policy with a $500,000 per-incident limit might have a $1.5 million aggregate limit. Reinsurance may impact aggregate limits, potentially allowing insurers to offer higher limits by sharing risk with other insurers.

With the capped total coverage amount of an aggregate limit, policyholders can better estimate and manage their potential insurance costs. They are also suitable for low-risk scenarios where the likelihood of multiple claims is minimal. However, once the aggregate limit is reached, no further claim expenses will be covered during the policy period, potentially leaving policyholders exposed.

Choosing incident and aggregate limits depends on your coverage needs and risk profile. Incident limits are beneficial for clear, manageable coverage for individual incidents, while aggregate limits offer broader protection for multiple claims over the policy period.

KristenHensleywTITLE

 

WebBannersNov26-02

Direct Written Premium vs. Earned Premium vs. Net Premium Earned

Direct Written Premium vs. Earned Premium vs. Net Premium Earned

Different types of premiums will impact operations and financial reporting. The terms Direct Written Premium (DWP), Earned Premium, and Net Premium each represent distinct aspects of the premium cycle. Let’s break down these terms and their implications.

Direct Written Premium (DWP)
Direct written premium refers to the total premiums an insurance company collects from policyholders, without adjustments for amounts ceded to reinsurers. It includes all premiums recorded within a year, minus any returned premiums. This figure reflects the gross income an insurance company generates from its policies before any reinsurance. In short, direct written premiums are the total amounts insurance companies charge for their policies. These do not account for any amounts transferred to other insurers (reinsurers). A high amount of direct premiums written generally indicates a strong financial position for the insurance company, assuming the pricing is adequate. Understanding DWP helps gauge an insurance company’s financial stability, which is useful when choosing an insurer.

Earned Premium
Earned premium is the portion of insurance premiums that an insurer has earned over time, based on the coverage period that has passed. It represents the amount the insurer can keep for the time the policy has been in effect. Once earned, the amount is non-refundable, even if the policy is canceled. Earned premiums contribute to an insurer’s profit by reducing their potential payout obligations. Insurers aim to maximize profits by managing risks and minimizing claims payments. Conversely, unearned premiums are those that an insurer has collected but not yet earned, often returned if the policy is canceled early.

Net Premium Earned
Net premium earned represents the adjusted amount of premiums an insurance company recognizes as earned over a specific period, accounting for changes in unearned premiums. This adjustment reflects the premiums earned throughout the year, after accounting for any premiums that are unearned at the start or end of the year. Net premium earned is calculated by subtracting unearned premium from written premium, reflecting the revenue earned during the accounting period. Insurance companies often use reinsurance to manage risk, which affects the calculation of net premiums. Gross premiums written represent the total premiums expected over the policy’s life, while net premiums written are the gross premiums minus reinsurance costs.

According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC):

  • Direct Written Premium: Total premiums received by an insurance company without any adjustments for the ceding of any portion of these premiums to the reinsurer.
  • Earned Premium: Portion of the insured’s prepaid premium allocated to the insurance company’s loss experience, expenses, and profit year-to-date.
  • Net Premium Earned: Premiums on property/casualty or health policies that will not have to be returned to the policyholder if the policy is canceled. 
References
  • “Direct Premium Written,” USA Coverage: Insurance Learning Center
  • “Earned Premium,” USA Coverage: Insurance Learning Center
  • “Net Premiums Earned,” USA Coverage: Insurance Learning Center
KristenHensleywTITLE

 

WebBannersNov26-07

Nose vs. Tail Coverage

While a policy can cover an insured through the time the policy is active, insureds may require a type of coverage for when they are in between insurance providers or transitioning from working to retiring. In claims-made professional insurance liability, there are two types of coverage options: tail coverage and nose (or prior acts) coverage. These two types of coverage share the characteristic of addressing coverage gaps related to timing; however, they vary in how they operate in practice.

Tail Coverage

Tail coverage or Extended Reporting Period (ERP) is an optional add-on to claims-made policy that allows insureds to report claims that arise after the policy expires but are based on incidents that occurred while the policy was active. Tail coverage is typically needed when a professional decides to retire, switch carriers, or cancel their claims-made policy. These decisions may cause a professional to no longer have coverage for claims made in the future, even if the incidents happened while the policy was in place. Tail Coverage ensures that these claims can still be reported even after the policy ends.

Tail coverage is purchased by the insureds, often for an additional premium, when the insured terminates their policy. The coverage typically allows claims to be reported for a specific time period: Examples can include one, three, or five years, or even indefinitely. The time period is dependent on the terms of the policy. Some policies feature a provision that offers tail coverage at no additional charge under specific circumstances like death, disability, and retirement.

A situation where tail coverage is needed, for instance, could be when a surgeon retires and cancels their professional liability insurance. If a lawsuit is filed two years later for an incident that occurred while the policy was active, tail coverage would allow the claim to be reported. Medical professionals entering the field who may be joining a medical group or system should determine who is responsible for paying the tail coverage if the physician looks for a different professional liability carrier.

Nose Coverage

Nose coverage, also known as prior acts coverage, is designed to cover claims for incidents that occurred before the insured’s new policy start date but were not reported under a previous claims-made policy. When switching insurers, nose coverage is commonly requested on the new insurer’s policy as an alternative to purchasing tail coverage from the prior insurer. Nose coverage is traditionally needed if a professional is switching insurers. This type of coverage ensures the professional is protected for claims arising from events that happened before the start of the new coverage.

Nose coverage is put into place when the new insurer agrees to cover claims made after the new policy begins but relating to acts that occurred before the new policy’s effective date. This coverage is typically arranged by defining a retroactive date, which dictates how far back the policy will cover prior incidents.

A case for nose coverage could be a physician switching to a new insurer. A patient files a claim against the physician arising from a diagnosis made 17 months before when the physician was covered by the previous insurer. If the physician’s new policy includes nose coverage with an appropriate retroactive date, then the claim will be reportable.

ChrisSweetwTitle

 

WebBannersNov26-09

Long Tail vs. Short Tail

Discovery periods and statutes of limitations heavily impact the nature of property/casualty insurance products

Some definitions

Long-tail insurance business involves claims that may be made long after the end of the insured period. These claims typically involve a claim period that is several years long—resulting in high amounts of incurred but not reported claims.1 Malpractice claims are a common example of long-tail insurance business, but other examples may include employment discrimination, certain cases of child abuse, and similar claims that require a lengthy settlement process.2

Meanwhile, short-tail insurance typically involves claims that are resolved relatively close to the exposure or occurrence that triggered the coverage. Common examples of short-tail insurance business include health or auto coverage.3

While statutes of limitations vary by state—and the circumstances surrounding a claim will vary—a general guideline is that long-tail insurance business takes a year or more for a claim to be settled, while short-tail insurance claims can often be settled in a year or less.

How long-tail business affects cash flow

Insurance companies that offer coverage for long-tail risks may have higher investment income ratios (net investment income / earned premiums). Policies covering long-tail risks typically have a larger gap between the time the premium is collected versus when any claims on that policy will need to be paid.

It is not uncommon for it to take years for a malpractice claim to go to trial. This puts significant pressure on professional liability insurers to ensure adequate pricing on their policies. The premium collected must be adequate to cover all claims-related expenses throughout the life of the claim. There is also significant pressure on both the insurance company and its insureds to maintain proper record keeping. Careful record retention and documentation are essential to both addressing regulatory requirements and ensuring the ability to provide the strongest possible defense should a case make its way to trial.

 

WebBannersNov26-11

PCF vs. JUA vs. Guaranty Funds

There are multiple resources managed by states—including patient compensation funds, joint underwriting associations, and guaranty funds—that support stakeholders in the medical professional liability market.

Patient Compensation Funds (PCF): A state-operated program to provide excess medical liability insurance coverage for eligible healthcare providers.

Eight states currently operate patient compensation funds (with Florida’s standard PCF dissolved in December 31, 2023), many funded by surcharges on the underlying coverage. They vary by state on features such as provider eligibility, coverage details, surcharges, residency requirements, requirements for underlying coverage, and more. Provider participation in these funds also varies by state. It is mostly voluntary in Indiana, Louisiana, Nebraska, and New Mexico, while in Kansas, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin participation is largely mandatory for most providers.

The compensation available under a patient compensation fund is in excess of underlying coverage obtained by eligible healthcare providers from their liability insurers. The funds also generally limit a provider’s liability to a specific amount. At the time the funds were created, they were seen as an effective way of increasing accessibility to medical malpractice insurance at a reasonable cost.[Schrero]

Visit the ProAssurance Resource Library for a brief history of PCF funds as well as details on participation, coverages, and other details of the existing state patient compensation programs, as well as information about states with birth-injury funds.

Joint Underwriting Association (JUA): A nonprofit risk-pooling association established by a state legislature as a response to an availability crisis in specific types of insurance coverage.[IRMI] It is created as a loss-sharing mechanism combining several insurance companies to provide extra capacity due to type or size of exposure.[NAIC] Participating carriers generally share in the profits and losses associated with the program.[iii (J)]

A number of states have established JUAs to provide medical professional liability insurance for physicians who are unable to obtain affordably priced insurance coverage in the standard marketplace.[IRMI]

Guaranty Funds: A state guaranty fund assumes responsibility for payment of covered claims to protect policyholders from “financial losses and delays in claims payments due to the insolvency of an insurance company.”[NAFA]

Guaranty funds are a solution for protecting insureds if an insurance company becomes insolvent. Initially developed as a single fund for one line, many states now have separate funds for various lines. Now every U.S. state plus Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and Washington, D.C., has implemented a guaranty fund [Investopedia] and all carriers are required to participate in these funds with an assessment of a percentage of their total net premiums.[NAFA]

ScottSpinolawTITLEupdate

 

WebBannersNov26-13

Hard vs. Soft Market

The medical professional liability market entered a soft market cycle in 2005, which has proved to be the longest soft market cycle the industry has ever experienced. Coverage was widely available, policy terms relaxed, and price based competition common.

Numerous medical malpractice jury verdicts and settlements in excess of $10M were seen in 2019 and continued into 2020 before courts shut down due to COVID-19. As courts reopen and delayed cases make their way into the courts, we are again seeing examples of excess verdicts throughout the country.

In a hard market cycle, insurance becomes less available, policy conditions tighten, and premiums increase. Medical malpractice claims may take a decade to resolve, so the insurers’ long-term financial health is of utmost importance to insureds. Many MPL specialty insurance companies were founded in response to the medical liability crisis of the 1970s.

Increased claim severity, largely due to excess jury awards, pushed combined ratios above 100 percent prior to the onset of the pandemic, putting pressure on rates. Excess verdicts then drove up the cost of reinsurance, worsening combined ratios even further. These financial pressures caused experienced MPL insurance companies to revisit pricing and policy terms.

WebBannersNov26-15

Admitted vs. Non-Admitted Insurance

An “admitted” insurance company—often referred to as a “standard market” insurance company—is one that has been licensed and approved by the insurance department of your state. Admitted carriers are subject to all state insurance regulations and must file their specific rates, rules, and forms that can be used.

“Non-admitted” carriers—often referred to as “excess and surplus lines” or “E&S” carriers—are free to draft their own insurance contracts and do not submit their forms and rates to state regulators for approval and acceptance. The enhanced flexibility allows for coverages and terms that are more customized to a specific account. While E&S carriers are not licensed by the state, they are authorized to do business in that state. Also while E&S insurers are not regulated by each state in which they do business, they do have to adhere to the regulations and guidelines of their domicile state.

Many states require that E&S insurers only write a policy if it has been rejected by admitted insurers, though some states have a list of eligible classes that are exempt from such a “diligent efforts” process. In all cases, the agent or broker placing coverage on an E&S policy must have a valid surplus lines license. Surplus lines carriers do not generally participate in state guaranty funds—funds administered by the state to pay claims in the event an insurer becomes insolvent. However, in most states they still must be approved by the state department of insurance to offer medical professional liability insurance and are subject to the same financial strength ratings as standard markets. Carriers must meet certain financial and regulatory criteria mandated by each state. These requirements usually include the establishment of substantial surplus and/or demonstration of adequate reinsurance.

States require E&S carriers to include a disclosure on the policy that lets the insured know the company is not covered by the state’s guaranty fund and the rates, rules, and forms have not been reviewed by the insurance department. When might you need an E&S carrier? The E&S insurance markets originated when those who needed insurance coverage were unable to secure it from the standard admitted companies. E&S carriers play a critical role in insuring higher risk healthcare groups such as hospitals, telemedicine groups, and physicians whose practice profile does not fit well with admitted carriers.

The typical types of risks written in E&S lines include those that:

    • Are considered high risk by the admitted market
    • Require higher limits than offered by standard markets
    • Require specialized or unique coverage
    • Have excessive or otherwise unacceptable loss history

E&S insurance policies can only be sold through licensed surplus lines brokers. If you need assistance finding a broker partner, visit Our Agency Partners page.

KristenHensleywTITLE

 

WebBannersNov26-17

RRGs vs. RPGs

Two alternatives to the standard insurance carrier for organizations seeking liability coverage are risk retention groups (RRG) and risk purchasing groups (RPG). The primary differences between RRGs and RPGs are who bears the group’s risks and how they are regulated. Both RPGs and RRGs are limited to placing liability coverage. [NAIC State Licensing Handbook]

Risk Retention Group (RRG)

An RRG is a liability insurance company owned by its members. As described by the NAIC, RRGs “allow businesses with similar insurance needs to pool their risks and form an insurance company that they operate under state regulated guidelines.” As an insurance entity, the RRG, therefore, bears the liability risks of the group’s members. RRGs operate under the applicable laws and regulations of their domiciled state as well as the federal Liability Risk Retention Act (LRRA), which enables their establishment. Some features of an RRG include: [NAIC]

    • All insureds of an RRG must be owners of the RRG.
    • All owners of the RRG must be insured through the RRG.
    • RRGs may be formed under a state’s captive or traditional insurance laws.

Another unique feature of a captive RRG that distinguishes it from other captives is that it can write directly in a non-domiciled state without obtaining a license “by completing a registration process and designating the state’s commissioner as agent for service of process.” For this reason, RRGs are treated like multi-state insurance companies and are subject to NAIC accreditation standards established to suit the unique nature of these entities. [NAIC]

Risk Purchasing Group (RPG)

An RPG is a group of insureds engaged in similar businesses or activities authorized to purchase insurance coverage from a commercial insurer. [IRMI]

RPGs are formed to pool the purchasing power of their members to negotiate favorable terms with insurance carriers. Because RPGs operate under the LRRA as purchasing entities marketed by insurers but are not themselves insurers, they are generally not subject to state insurance laws. [NAIC State Licensing Handbook] Carriers selling policies to RPGs must generally follow the transaction regulations in that state. Therefore, both admitted and surplus lines insurers and producers must follow appointment and licensing rules as appropriate for their line of business. [NAIC State Licensing Handbook]

ScottSpinolawTITLEupdate

 

WebBannersNov26-19

Occurrence vs. Claims-Made

There are two basic types of medical professional liability insurance policies: “occurrence” and “claims-made” coverage. Among insureds, there’s often confusion as to the difference between the two. Because the type of policy directly affects the kind of coverage you will have, it’s important they understand how each type works.

The major difference between these policy forms is how coverage is provided:

  • Occurrence policies cover incidents that occur during the policy period regardless of when they are reported. There is no need to purchase tail coverage (reflected in the higher premium charged for this coverage), but the buyer’s coverage is restricted to the limits purchased during that policy period.
  • Claims-made policies cover incidents that are reported/made during the active policy period—on or after the retroactive date and before the policy expiration date. Tail coverage must be purchased to provide continuing protection for incidents reported after the policy expiration date.

Claims-made coverage is the most economical professional liability coverage form for physicians, dentists, and other professionals in the United States today. With a claims-made policy, an insured can increase their policy limits or add coverages as needs change or as new coverages become available. The claims-made policy is more flexible and provides considerable cost savings during the early years.

Claims-made coverage eliminates some of the uncertainty created by the long-tail nature of medical professional liability claims (i.e., how long it takes a claim to be resolved as measured from the date of the originating incident). It may offer more flexibility and enables ProAssurance to provide coverage and rates that more accurately reflect the ever-changing healthcare environment and any potential losses.  

Coverage Features

A ProAssurance claims-made policy provides for tail coverage in the event of death or disability. Insureds also receive tail coverage upon full retirement when continuously covered by ProAssurance on a claims-made basis for a minimum of five years.

For large healthcare organizations, ProAssurance offers tail coverage on both an admitted and excess basis. Insureds can work with their insurance agent to choose from a variety of personalized coverage options, including a deductible, subject to underwriting approval.

Will Tail Coverage Be Needed?

Tail coverage is necessary upon retirement or otherwise ceasing the practice of medicine. If you are moving coverage from an occurrence policy, tail coverage is not necessary. If you are moving coverage from another insurer’s claims-made policy, this coverage may be handled under the prior acts coverage of the new claims-made policy.  

With a ProAssurance policy, tail coverage is available—whether for a premium charge or at no additional cost.

KristenHensleywTITLE

 

WebBannersNov26-20

Economic vs. Noneconomic Damages

When a healthcare provider faces a claim or lawsuit following a patient injury or adverse event, that defendant provider’s medical professional liability (MPL) insurance becomes very important. If that provider is found liable for the patient’s injury and coverage is available, the MPL insurance policy could compensate the patient for the damage.

These compensatory damages include economic and noneconomic damages.

Economic Damages
Economic damages, sometimes called actual compensatory damages, refer to quantifiable financial losses resulting from the harm caused by a defendant. In a healthcare context, these typically include:

  • Past and future medical expenses
  • Lost wages
  • Loss of earning capacity
  • Out-of-pocket expenses

The hallmark of economic damages is that they can be supported by documentation such as medical bills, pay stubs, employment records, and expert testimony regarding projected future costs.

Noneconomic Damages
Noneconomic damages, sometimes called general compensatory damages, compensate for intangible, subjective losses that significantly impact quality of life but cannot be precisely quantified. These include:

  • Pain and suffering
  • Loss of enjoyment of life
  • Mental anguish
  • Injury to reputation
  • Physical impairment and disfigurement

Unlike economic damages, noneconomic damages cannot be calculated using receipts or invoices. They require subjective assessment of how the injury has impacted the patient’s daily life.

Note: Coverage under a policy depends on the terms of the policy and the circumstances of the claim.

References

“Ending the Confusion: Economic, Non-Economic, and Punitive Damages,” American College of Surgeons, https://www.facs.org/advocacy/federal-legislation/liability/guide-to-liability-reform/ending-the-confusion/.

Legal Information Institute, 42 USC § 247d-6d(e)(8), https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/247d-6d#e_8.

“Compensatory Damages: Definition, Types, and Examples,” Investopedia, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/compensatory-damages.asp.

KristenHensleywTITLE

 

WebBannersNov26-21
Bad Faith

First vs. Third Party

A medical professional liability policy represents a contractual agreement between an insurance company and its policyholder. In this agreement the insured pays a premium, and the insurer provides them with financial protections in the event of a claim. The insurance company is expected to fulfill certain duties on behalf of their policyholder in a fair and reasonable manner, and in good faith. These duties include properly investigating a claim made against the policyholder and defending that person if the claim is covered in their policy. The insurer will pay associated settlement costs, court-related expenses, and court-ordered damages, and should evaluate settling a case if a reasonable settlement is possible and warranted. This helps protect the insured from out-of-pocket losses that may result if there is a lawsuit.1

If the insurance carrier fails to meet these obligations when handling a claim for their client, or exhibits any of the below behaviors, they may be acting in bad faith:1,2

    • Denying a claim that clearly should be covered, without reasonable justification
    • Refusing to investigate a claim—or conducting an investigation of a claim—without good reason
    • Misrepresenting policy terms and language, or nondisclosure of policy provisions or exclusions, to avoid payment of a claim
    • Not considering evidence suggesting a claim should be covered and instead seeking justification for denial of the claim
    • Refusal to settle a case (as requested by the policyholder) when a policyholder is clearly liable, and making that insured person vulnerable to a lawsuit and potential damages exceeding policy limits
    • Exhibiting other actions to deliberately avoid obligations under the insurance policy

When an insured makes a claim with their own insurance company, requesting payment for a covered loss, this is known as a first-party claim. If the insurance company fails to fulfill its contractual duties or does not process a claim in a fair or appropriate manner, the insured can file a claim of first-party bad faith against that insurer. An insured may be able to recover compensation for resulting financial losses, court fees, statutory penalties, even emotional distress. These awards vary depending on state law, common law rules for jurisdictions, the nature of the insurance company’s misconduct, and the type of loss.1

When a third party (someone other than the policyholder or their insurance company) makes a claim against that person’s insurer under the policy, this is known as a third-party bad faith claim. The claimant may have been injured by the policyholder, for example, and is alleging that the policyholder’s insurer did not appropriately handle their claim, perhaps by failing to provide full or adequate compensation. It is the duty of the insurance company to defend the insured person, not the third-party claimant. However, they still have an obligation to properly investigate and resolve that person’s claim in a reasonable manner.1

Proving bad faith is not always simple or straightforward, and the exact terms of bad faith do vary by state. An insurance company does reserve the right to deny a claim when it is clear the loss is not covered in a policy. That insurer must, however, provide justification for it.1 State laws are intended to help protect consumers from unfair claims practices and ensure an insured receives the benefits and coverage for which they are entitled.1,2 Many states do require proof of intentional, purposeful, or egregious action on the part of the insurer for a wrongful denial, to establish that bad faith has occurred.1 A simple mistake in claim handling would not constitute bad faith. Neither would a difference of opinion between the policyholder and adjuster regarding a loss amount, unless the adjuster cannot provide reasonable support for their findings.2

References

1. Christy Bieber, “What Is a Bad Faith Insurance Claim?” Forbes, September 8, 2023, https://www.forbes.com/advisor/legal/personal-injury/bad-faith-insurance/
2. Julia Kagan, “What Is Bad Faith Insurance and How Companies Can Act,” Investopedia, April 20, 2023,
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/b/bad-faith-insurance.asp
3. “Insurance Bad Faith and Related Topics,” FindLaw, last reviewed October 31, 2017,
https://corporate.findlaw.com/corporate-governance/insurance-bad-faith-and-related-topics.html

KaelinOReillywTitleUpdate

 

WebBannersNov26-22

ALAE vs. ULAE

A medical malpractice case generally starts when a policyholder notifies their insurance company that they received a communication making a demand for money damages or threatening or initiating a lawsuit. A policyholder may also reach out to their insurance carrier for advice after an adverse event. After these types of policyholder contact, the insurance company’s claims department begins their claim investigation process.

Typically, the claims department will open a claim and begin the investigation process. Naturally, there are costs incurred by the insurance company for every claim they handle as well as simply maintaining a claims department. These cumulative costs are known as loss adjustment expenses (LAE).1

Calculating ALAE and ULAE

Some LAE are general in nature and do not apply to any one claim, and others are specific to a single claim. To differentiate between these categories (and to comply with applicable regulations and industry standards), the insurance industry defines expenses as either allocated or unallocated.2 The essential difference between them comes down to allocation, i.e., distribution for a particular purpose.

Allocated Loss Adjustment Expenses (ALAE): costs attributable to a particular claim.

Some examples include:1,2

  • Claim-specific investigation costs
  • Expert witness fees
  • Billable attorney fees

Unallocated Loss Adjustment Expenses (ULAE): costs expended for general claims operations.

Some examples include:1,2

  • Claims personnel salaries
  • General office expenses
  • Maintenance costs of vehicles used in claims investigations

How LAE Impacts Our Finances

Investigating a claim is a critical element of the claims process and a significant component of LAE. An investigation will help determine the severity and defensibility of a claim as well as protect against fraudulent claims. In this sense, LAE can help limit loss expenses. LAE is also a component of the combined ratio along with these additional components:2

  • Incurred losses: settlements and jury awards
  • Other underwriting expenses: the cost of daily underwriting activities
  • Earned premiums: the premium applicable to the portion of the policy that has expired

ALAE vs. ULAE Combined Ratio = Incurred Losses + LAE + Other Underwriting Expenses Earned Premiums

The combined ratio is an important indicator of an insurance company’s profitability, showing how claim and underwriting expenses are offset by earned premiums. A combined ratio below 100% means an insurer earns more premium than it expends on claim and underwriting expenses, including LAE. That makes limiting LAE an important financial goal for an insurance company.

ScottSpinolawTITLEupdate

 

WebBannersNov26-23

Combined vs. Expense Ratio

Insurance companies can use simple calculations to measure their profitability and glean a clearer picture of their financial health regarding revenues and losses. The combined ratio and expense ratio are two such examples.

A combined ratio is a measure of underwriting profitability that gauges an insurance company’s performance in daily operations for a given period. It measures the insurer’s losses (paid claims and reserves) and expenses (operating costs) against earned premiums collected from policies. This reveals a percentage that indicates the efficiency of underwriting and management and the ability of a company to drive growth and earn profit.

The combined ratio is found by taking the sum of incurred losses (related to evaluating, defending, and paying claims) and operational expenses (underwriting costs, employee salaries, advertising, commissions, etc.) and dividing that by the earned net premium of new and recurring business.

PRV 1

For example, one insurer collects and earns $4,000 in policy premiums, pays out $2,400 in claims, and has $1,000 in operational expenses. The combined ratio would be $3,400 (losses plus expenses) divided by the $4,000 in earned premium, or 85%.

A combined ratio below 100% indicates a company making an underwriting profit. A ratio above 100% indicates the company pays more money in claims and expenses than it receives from premiums. The above example shows a company making a profit.

This ratio is not the only indicator of a company’s drive toward profitability or unprofitability, though many insurers consider it the best indicator as it does not account for investment income. A company with a high combined ratio could still make profit through investments.1

Another measure, the expense ratio, indicates how efficiently a company uses its resources to pay expenses, comparing an insurer’s expenses to what it can expect to receive in revenues.2 This ratio shows how much premium is used to attain, underwrite, and service policies.3 In other words, how expensive is it for an insurer to operate its business? The expense ratio is found by dividing the underwriting expenses (underwriting costs, employee salaries, advertising, commissions, etc.) by net earned premiums.2

PRV 2

Like the combined ratio, this calculation does not factor in gains and losses made through investments. It also does not include incurred losses related to claims payments and reserves on policies written. The higher the expense ratio, the lower the net returns will be. A ratio under 100% indicates a company writing more premiums than it pays in underwriting expenses.2

Using the same company above as an example, total expenses ($1,000) divided by earned premiums ($4,000) gives an expense ratio of 25%.

Subject Matter Experts: Chris Sweet & Bradley Byrne 

References

1. Adam Hayes, “Combined Ratio: Definition, What It Measures, Formula, Examples,” Investopedia, July 31, 2020, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/combinedratio.asp

2. Andrew Sebastian, “What Is the Expense Ratio in the Insurance Industry?” Investopedia, September 12, 2023, https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/102915/what-expense-ratio-insurance-industry.asp#

3. National Association of Insurance Commissioners, “Glossary of Insurance Terms,” accessed August 2024, https://content.naic.org/consumer_glossary#C

KaelinOReillywTitleUpdate

 

WebBannersNov26-24

Reporting Year vs. Accident Year

Understanding the distinction between a reporting year and an accident year is crucial in the insurance industry for lines of business like medical professional liability (MPL).

In general, these terms and others, like fiscal year or calendar year, refer to the grouping or organization of business data (earnings and losses) for a certain period of time for comparison and analysis. Businesses may choose a year, quarter, month, or any other established timeframe that gives them the best view of their financial picture and allows them to assess company profitability and performance.1,2

What is the significance of “accident year” and “reporting year” in MPL insurance? As noted, these terms represent a method of collecting financial data. They also reference two medical malpractice policy types: claims-made and occurrence.

Reporting Year

Claims-Made Policies

A reporting year is a 12-month period that includes the report date, or the day on which an alleged incident preceding a claim, incident report, or lawsuit was reported to an insurance company, regardless of when the incident occurred.3,

In claims-made coverage, a provider is covered against any claims reported within policy active dates (on or after the retroactive date—the first day of coverage—and before the expiration date).4 Accounting for a reporting year would compare losses reported in that 12-month period against premiums earned to determine profit, or whether premiums exceeded losses and expenses.

Accident Year

Occurrence Policies

An accident year refers to any 12-month period during which incidents and losses occurred and insurance policy premiums were earned, regardless of when those losses were reported.5

An occurrence policy covers an insured for incidents that occur within the policy active dates. Accounting for accident year July 2023 to June 2024, for example, would compare the losses that occurred within these dates to the premiums earned, to determine profit.4,5

Some confusion may arise when considering a calendar year, the period commonly recognized as January 1 through December 31 (based on the Gregorian calendar). A calendar year comprises an individual’s or business’s financial information (payments and transactions, losses and revenues) for accounting and tax filing.6

Most MPL claim payment transactions will show up later than the reporting and accident year data and will be represented in calendar year data. For example, when an MPL insurance company views financial information for calendar year 2023, they would see all policy-related transactions, premiums, and paid claims that were processed in that year, regardless of when the associated losses occurred or claims were reported. These transactions can represent multiple policy periods from previous years due to the time it would take to investigate, settle, and eventually pay the claim.

Subject Matter Experts: Sokol Berisha, Tonya Bussey, Bradley Byrne, Elaine Sparks 

References 1. Will Kenton, “Accounting Period: What It Is, How It Works, Types, and Requirements,” Investopedia, September 28, 2022, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/accountingperiod.asp
2. “Insurance Definitions: Accident year data,” International Risk Management Institute (IRMI), accessed August 21, 2024, https://www.irmi.com/term/insurance-definitions/accident-year-data
3. “Medical Professional Liability Terminology: Report Date,” ProAssurance, accessed September 6, 2024, https://proassurance.com/knowledge-center/medical-professional-liability-terminology
4. “Tail Coverage: Claims-Made vs. Occurrence Coverage,” ProAssurance, accessed September 6, 2024, https://proassurance.com/tail-coverage
5. Will Kenton, “Accident Year Experience: Meaning, Overview, Calculation,” Investopedia, March 26, 2022, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/accident-year-experience.asp
6. Will Kenton, “Calendar Year Meaning vs. Fiscal Year, Pros & Cons,” Investopedia, February 11, 2022, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/calendaryear.asp
KaelinOReillywTitleUpdate

 

WebBannersNov26-25

Life vs. Health vs. Property & Casualty Insurance

Insurance Basics

There are many forms of insurance available to consumers today, offering protection for everything from our health, vehicles, and homes, even our pets and travel plans.1,2 Most Americans have at least one of these coverages, with health, life, homeowners, and auto among the most common. Insurance is purchased with the hope that it might never be needed. However, those with a policy have peace of mind knowing that during unexpected and challenging circumstances they have the financial support they need to manage certain risks and protect themselves, their families, and their assets.1

Generally speaking, insurance is “a contract, represented by a policy, in which a policyholder receives financial protection or reimbursement against losses from an insurance company.” In exchange for regularly paid premiums, the policyholder and any covered family members are safeguarded financially (in full or in part) during a policy term for certain covered incidents or unforeseen circumstances. These may include an accident, theft, adverse weather, or a natural disaster resulting in bodily injury, illness, or damage to personal assets or property. The cost of a policy can depend on multiple factors, including age, sex, and perceived level of risk. The policyholder may be required to pay a specific amount “out of pocket” in the form of a deductible before the policy coverage kicks in and the insurance company begins paying the claim.1

It would be outside the scope of this article to cover the nuances of every known insurance plan. However, it is worth taking a look at some of the policy types that may be mentioned in discussions around healthcare and medical practice but that each serve distinct purposes: health, life, and property & casualty.

Health Insurance

Health insurance helps cover medical-related expenses, such as routine office visits, medications, procedures, and hospitalizations.3 A health insurance policy can be purchased through the private insurance market or the federal government (Healthcare.gov, Medicare, or Medicaid) during open enrollment periods or for a qualifying life event, like a pregnancy or marriage.1,3 Many companies offer employees health insurance plan options for free or at discounted rates (in addition to dental and vision plans) as part of their benefits packages.1,2 Individuals may also be covered under a family member’s plan or by purchasing a floater plan.4

In a health insurance policy, the policyholder (insured) pays a regular premium, and the insurance company (insurer) covers some or all of their medical expenses related to an illness, condition, or injury.4 Premium costs vary depending on the individual insurance company, the potential insured’s age and health status, and the type of coverage options or levels available. An insured may also be responsible for copays and an annual deductible to pay for covered services, though some preventive care services may be available for free.1

Life Insurance

While a health insurance policy helps protect the well-being of a living person, a life insurance policy offers financial support for family members or loved ones left behind after that person dies. The insured pays premiums for this coverage while they are living, and chosen beneficiaries are awarded a benefit payment after the insured’s death.1 This payment can replace the deceased’s salary and cover the beneficiaries’ various financial obligations including funeral and burial costs, mortgage payments, outstanding debt, future college tuition, and everyday living expenses like groceries or childcare.5

Two common types of life insurance policies are term and whole, though there are other options. A term life policy, typically the most affordable, covers a specific period, like 10 years or 20 years, and the premiums remain the same. A whole life policy includes a death benefit and cash value component. As the value increases, the money may be accessed by taking out a loan or withdrawing the funds. The policyholder may choose to end the policy during their lifetime by taking its cash value.5

Property & Casualty (P&C)

This is an umbrella term for several types of insurance policies including homeowners, renters, auto, and business insurance, to name a few.6 These policies provide protection for individuals or businesses for covered events such as accidents, theft, natural disasters, or other unexpected circumstances.7 The property portion of this insurance typically covers commercial assets or personal assets like the home, cars, or valuables and helps pay for any repairs or replacements if these items are lost, damaged, or stolen. The casualty portion covers liability, including legal fees or medical expenses associated with bodily injury to another person or damage to their possessions.6

One P&C category, business insurance, helps cover both large and small businesses from a variety of industry-specific risks including worker accidents, business interruption due to a covered event, and cybersecurity threats. Policies might protect commercial buildings, equipment, inventory, and technology from potential loss or damage. Business insurance is broken down further to include business liability insurance and professional liability insurance.7

Medical professional liability, or medical malpractice insurance, is one type of professional liability insurance. Its purpose is to protect physicians and other licensed healthcare providers (like nurses or dentists) from certain practice-related risks. In the event of a liability claim or lawsuit alleging an adverse outcome, such as a patient injury, a medical liability policy will help cover the costs of the provider’s defense, including legal fees. The two basic types of medical liability policies are claims-made and occurrence. For the former, an insured provider would need to have an effective policy during the time a claim is reported. In an occurrence policy, the provider is protected against losses that occur during the policy period.8

References 1. Julia Kagan, “Insurance: Definition, How It Works, and Main Types of Policies,” Investopedia, February 28, 2024, https://www.investopedia.com/terms/i/insurance.asp
2. Adam Carpenter, “Insurance Glossary: Insurance,” S. News & World Report, February 15, 2024, https://www.usnews.com/insurance/glossary/what-is-insurance
3. https://www.usatoday.com/money/money-essentials/insurance/
4. Rashi Maheshwari, “What Is Health Insurance: Meaning, Benefits & Types,” Forbes, December 27, 2023, https://www.forbes.com/advisor/in/health-insurance/what-is-health-insurance/
5. Linda McMaken, “4 Types of Insurance Policies and Coverage You Need,” Investopedia, December 20, 2023, https://www.investopedia.com/financial-edge/0212/4-types-of-insurance-everyone-needs.aspx
6. Rick Hoel, “What is Property and Casualty Insurance?,” Bankrate, May 8, 2023, https://www.bankrate.com/insurance/car/property-and-casualty/
7. “What Types of Property and Casualty Insurance Are There?,” Guidewire, accessed September 3, 2024, https://www.guidewire.com/resources/insurance-technology-faq/what-types-of-property-and-casualty-insurance-are-there
8. “Medical Malpractice Insurance,” National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), last updated May 9, 2024, https://content.naic.org/insurance-topics/medical-malpractice-insurance
KaelinOReillywTitleUpdate

 

WebBannersNov26-26

Paid vs. Incurred Medical Expenses

The terms paid and incurred medical expenses are applicable both in considering billing for healthcare services and in calculating damage awards in a medical malpractice case. In accounting terms, when goods and services are requested and delivered to a consumer, they are incurred and paid. Similarly, incurred medical expenses are the amounts billed by a healthcare provider to a patient for services related to the treatment and prevention of a disease or injury. These amounts are calculated before any applicable reductions are made, such as through a patient’s health insurance coverage. Paid medical expenses refer to amounts paid for these services, whether by the patient’s insurance or out of pocket.

In health insurance coverage, the final amount billed for services is usually a reduced amount depending on the contractual agreement between carrier and provider and on the types of services provided. A patient’s policy may cover various medical expenses depending on the coverage limits and deductible. Those can include office visits, procedures, prescriptions, therapy, and other treatments. A patient would be responsible for any amounts beyond those covered by their policy, and that portion is usually subject to a deductible and some type of copay.

When a healthcare provider faces a claim or lawsuit following a patient injury or adverse event, that defendant provider’s medical professional liability insurance (MPL) is triggered. Their
policy can pay associated defense costs, including legal and attorney fees, for a covered professional incident. Their insurance would also cover compensatory payments, or economic and noneconomic damages, if the provider is found liable for the patient’s injury or condition. Noneconomic damages are subjective complaints that cannot be quantified (such as pain and suffering or emotional distress). Economic damages are losses that can be quantified or given a monetary value, such as lost wages or medical expenses.

In a court settlement, compensation for medical damages is based on a number of factors, including what would reasonably or customarily cover past, present, and future treatments and care, and the patient’s overall financial impact, for instance. Further, incurred and paid medical expenses are treated differently from state to state in this determination. Most if not all states will allow the patient to enter into evidence the total amount billed/incurred for medical expenses related to their injury or event. Another state may allow the defense to enter into evidence the actual amounts paid by the health insurance carrier and the patient. Some states only allow the amount billed and prohibit the defense from entering paid amounts into evidence. The amount may also be subject to a lien by the health insurance carrier for the benefits paid under their policy. It is then left to the jury to decide what amount to award the plaintiff.

Subject Matter Experts: Mark Helsloot, Director Claims, Jan Harris, Director Claims, and Cory Conklin, Lead Claims Specialist 

KaelinOReillywTitleUpdate

 

WebBannersNov26-27

Avoidance vs. Prevention vs. Reduction

While there is inherent risk when providing healthcare, there are risk mitigation strategies that—if applied—may help reduce the exposure, aka, risk. None of these strategies are perfect, and different risk scenarios may be best addressed with different strategies or with more than one strategy in combination. There is also overlap in the strategies. Risk mitigation often overlaps with risk reduction but may also include measures to manage and control risks once they do occur. Proactive measures and risk management tools often involve one or more of these strategies.

  • Avoidance seeks to eliminate potential risks before they can impact patients or organizations. Avoidance is also not always possible, though. For example, it would not be practical for an ob-gyn to cease treating pregnant women to avoid the risk of birth injuries. (risk management tools: policies and procedures)
  • Prevention is the process of avoiding or impeding actions that could result in an adverse event. It focuses on eliminating or significantly reducing adverse events, identifying the risks, and then implementing strategies to prevent the risk from materializing. (risk management tools: risk assessment, SBAR tool, standardizing processes and procedures, staff training and education, medication management, infection prevention safety, using data analytics)
  • Reduction involves lessening the likelihood and severity of an adverse event; it accepts that some level of risk is inevitable and focuses on minimizing its impact. (risk management tools: ongoing education and training, monitoring, and continuous improvement)
WebBannersNov26-28

Operational vs. Clinical Risk Management

Risk management is the ongoing and systematic process of identifying, evaluating, and mitigating the potential threats, vulnerabilities, and events that negatively impact businesses or organizations. Its methods include analyzing the likelihood and severity of these threats on daily operations and developing strategies to help minimize or prevent losses while encouraging business growth. Consistent monitoring and reporting are implemented to assess the effectiveness of these strategies and to identify new or developing threats. This article focuses on two types of risk management: operational and clinical risk management.

Operational Risk Management

Operational risk refers to the potential weaknesses or issues a company or organization may exhibit in its routine functions and activities. There may be risks inherent in the priorities, policies, and decision-making of the organization, any of which can lead to disruptions or failures. Rather than focusing specifically on what is produced, operational risk management focuses on how businesses run, their workforces, and the human-made errors in processes, controls, and systems that effectively threaten a business’ assets and reputation.

The causes of risk are as unique as any organization, but these are the primary sources:

  • People: Staff shortages, lack of knowledge or training, misappropriation of company resources or participation in fraud, high turnover, and poor retention
  • Processes: Incomplete development or documentation of a process, improper performance of sequential steps (leading to breakdowns or slowed production), failed monitoring of internal controls, deployment of inadequate strategies, failure to implement safety measures or meet government compliance
  • Systems: Outdated or underperforming software, hardware failures, overestimation of system capabilities, vulnerabilities, and exposures (causing data breaches or other cybercrimes), insufficient equipment maintenance
  • External Events: Natural disasters or weather events, political or economic changes, failed third-party business contracts, unreliable suppliers

All businesses in any industry incur at least some level of risk, and no risk management plan will eliminate every problem or shortcoming. Senior leaders must work across departments to assess and evaluate the impact and severity of risk in their organization, determine their appropriate risk tolerance, and develop a plan for handling both predictable and unforeseen challenges. A good risk management plan will help teams recognize and prioritize threats and develop effective, coordinated techniques to mitigate them. This helps a business run smoothly, reducing incidents of harm or loss while keeping costs down and avoiding heavy regulatory fines.

Assessing Operational Risk

Operational risk assessment begins with identifying what could go wrong in the day-to-day activities of a company and deciding which issues are most crucial to mitigate, and which may be more acceptable. A manufacturer, for example, may ask which vendor has been most consistent in delivering materials on time, while a radiology clinic may consider what might happen if one of their MRI machines breaks down. Organizations monitor key risk indicators (KRIs), quantifiable and trackable benchmarks that are applied to different components of a business or specific areas of concern:

  • Customer Service (response times, complaints)
  • Customer or Patient Satisfaction (survey scores)
  • Team Member Performance (morale, absences)
  • Efficiency of Processes (machine breakdowns, automations)
  • Product Reliability (breakdowns, reviews)
  • Security (IT patches, data breaches, recovery times)

These indicators provide insightful data that is collected and reported to guide the development of company best practices and policies and to maintain regulatory compliance. KRIs can answer important questions on the above components:

  • Are current controls keeping risk levels within an acceptable threshold?
  • Are there new areas of exposure?
  • How effectively and proficiently are lower-level teams handling and resolving issues using the current processes?
  • Where is there room for improvement?

Businesses will determine the KRIs that best suit their framework and needs. These may be developed through automated means using financial or industry data, or third-party surveys. IT services might include risk indicator systems as part of their packages.

Managing Operational Risk

Businesses use many different approaches and strategies to manage risk, but there are a few basic methods:

Avoidance of Unnecessary Risk: An organization might avoid taking on risks that do not bring reward. This requires continuous monitoring and evaluation of potential risks to determine whether they are worth the investment and provide good returns.

Performing Cost/Benefit Analysis: This method evaluates benefits versus costs. Does the benefit potential of a business decision outweigh the risk?

Delegation: The designation of a member of upper management to approach strategies and make decisions regarding risk management is usually appropriate. This individual will have a solid understanding of the company and the industry as a whole, but may counsel with legal teams, providers, and other stakeholders to gather more information.

Anticipation: An awareness for potential risks and their outcomes can assist businesses in formulating a plan of action for overseeing those risks. Gathering information or research (on consumer preferences or geographical limitations, for example) helps a team determine whether to manage or avoid that risk.

Clinical Risk Management

The purpose of clinical risk management is to identify, mitigate, and prevent risks associated with patient care and healthcare institutions. Clinical risk management addresses circumstances that contribute to medical errors, that compromise patient safety, and that have bearing on an organization’s financial health and reputation. The process endorses a culture of teamwork and transparency, relying on the understanding and willingness of all parties involved in patient care to participate in identifying, reporting, learning from, and preventing adverse events. Operational risk management is also applied to healthcare practices because of the potential for error in the human-created controls and systems that play a role in patient care and in the functioning of a hospital or other medical facility.

Adverse and Sentinel Events

An “adverse event” is broadly defined as a negative outcome that occurs when a patient is provided medical care such as a medication, procedure, or other treatment. The event is either preventable or nonpreventable, may prolong hospitalization and can be any level of severity from injury to disability, psychological trauma, and even patient death. An adverse event is often caused not by the natural course of an illness or condition, but by error associated with patient care including errors of commission or omission, substandard practice, near misses, or close calls.

According to The Joint Commission, a “sentinel event,” a subcategory of medical error, is “a patient safety event that results in death, permanent harm, or severe, temporary harm.” A medical error will fall under this category if it is considered severe. There are many processes and dynamics in day-to-day healthcare and, with them, a myriad of opportunities for errors or mistakes. The following, however, are commonly cited “high-risk processes” or conditions and their potential implications:

  • Surgical Site Verification (wrong-site surgeries)
  • Patient Handoffs
  • Specimen Labeling (mislabeling)
  • Diagnoses (incorrect or missed)
  • Patient Identification (wristbands)
  • Device or Equipment Function (failures, breakdowns)
  • Medication Dosing (incorrect medication or missed dose)
  • Staffing (shortage, high patient-to-provider ratios)
  • Work-Related Falls (injuries)
  • Provider Condition (sleep deprivation, burnout)

The Joint Commission requires that each accredited healthcare organization establish its own definition of a sentinel event in order to develop an appropriate risk management plan for investigation, reporting, response, and prevention. Effective risk-mitigation strategies will help reduce future incidents and promote safety for patients and team members, facilitating an improved quality of care. As stated, the safety of patients and prevention of negative events and injuries is a team effort. Clinical risk management encourages all parties (regardless of status or longevity) from administrators and physicians to nurses and technicians, support staff, patients, family members, and volunteers to openly participate in patient safety and voice any concerns they may have. It may be individual actions that lead to error, but effective clinical risk management ultimately falls to the institution, focusing not on performance but on established and implemented systemic policies and protocols.

Key Components of Clinical Risk Management

The practice of risk management in healthcare has become more complex over time, with greater consideration of expanding technologies, a high incidence of cybersecurity issues, and a constantly evolving regulatory, legal, and reimbursement landscape. Because of this, hospitals and healthcare systems are taking more of a proactive approach to risk management. They are focusing not just on promotion of patient safety and prevention of legal exposures, but on viewing risk in terms of the “big picture,” or the healthcare ecosystem. Risk management plans develop from regular communication and cooperation between the risk manager and multiple stakeholders across all departments. An effective plan will serve as a “living document.” Both clinical and administrative systems and reporting criteria are updated and improved based on new and emerging risks, lessons learned, and changes to healthcare systems and practice trends. Continuous monitoring of these dynamics is necessary, as is ongoing education and training (including for emergencies and contingencies) to help team members stay prepared for change and give providers the tools to provide quality care with fewer potential liabilities.

An effective clinical risk management plan should:

Identify Risks: Uncovering current and developing threats that may compromise patient safety or lead to a liability or compensatory event. A risk manager will lead their team in proactively recognizing and identifying all threats to the healthcare institution. This includes using data benchmarking and applying organizational and industry knowledge. It means engaging with patients, healthcare team members, insurers, and administrators to find risks that might not be immediately apparent.

Quantify and Prioritize: Assigning a score to the risk or event based on its likelihood to occur and its impact or severity. The appropriate risk-mitigating resources are chosen and tasks assigned based on these metrics and on communication and collaboration.

Investigate and Report Adverse and Sentinel Events: Timely response and thorough investigation and evaluation following an adverse event, which reduces the chance of recurrence. This means having an established plan that encourages a calm response with appropriate and measured corrective action to address any safety issues. Cooperation and trust between teams and leaders enable transparency and a more complete evaluation of those corrective actions.

Perform Compliance Reporting: Documentation, coding, and reporting of events such as medication errors, device malfunctions, or injuries to state and federal governing bodies to maintain compliance and avoid fines.

Catch Near-Misses/Learn from Mistakes: Identifying risks by chance or catching “near-misses,” mistakes that could have led to an adverse event. Providers should encourage reporting of these instances, as the information gleaned helps guide best practices and prevent future risk events.

Use Analysis Models: Applying proven models for error and accident analysis. Analysis models like Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) or Root Cause Analysis help improve efficiency and effectiveness of a risk management plan by helping uncover the causes and effects of mistakes in a healthcare practice.

Invest in a Risk Management Information System (RMIS): These aid risk management efforts by providing a platform and tools for documenting incidents, reporting trends, and collecting and comparing data. Information systems generate reports for incidents, injuries, claims, and other statistics. They also keep costs down by automating processes.

Find a Balance: Financing risk, applying methods to fund losses, and transferring risk through an insurance policy or risk retention (self-insurance or captive insurance).

Subject Matter Experts: Laurette Cote, Kelly Riedl 

KaelinOReillywTitleUpdate

 

WebBannersNov26-29
What’s the Difference?

Medical Licensing

When pursuing healthcare as a patient or a career, it can be a bit daunting sorting through the various licenses and specialties. MD, DO, NP, RN, LPN ... what’s the difference? While licensing regulations and medical board standards vary by state, we’ll attempt to sort out some of the major differences between the various healthcare providers.

Medical Doctor vs. Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine

Doctors of medicine (MD) and doctors of osteopathic medicine (DO) receive the most extensive training among healthcare professionals. They both have the same responsibilities and privileges in treating patients, can prescribe medication, and can practice independently. Each receives a four-year undergraduate degree, attends four years of medical school (MD) or college of osteopathic medicine (DO), and completes three to seven years of residency training after receiving a medical degree. Some MDs and DOs also go on to fellowships to train in a specialty.

Both MDs and DOs diagnose and treat acute and chronic illnesses. Where they differ is in their approach to medicine. An MD focuses on the diagnosis and treatment of diseases, observing symptoms, and treating them directly. While a DO uses some of those same methods, they take a more holistic approach, considering the entire body system, nutrition, and everyday environment as factors in patient health. A DO must also take additional hours of training in the skill of osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT) to learn how the bones, nerves, and muscles work together and influence health.1

Advanced Practice Providers

Advanced practice provider (APP) is a broad category rather than a specific medical license. APPs include physician assistants (PAs) and advanced practice registered nurses (APRNs), among others. The roles of the different APPs are similar and often overlap with physicians, although their duties such as prescribing privileges and practicing independently vary by state. Depending on the specific APP license, the education requirement could be as short as six years (a bachelor’s degree and a master’s degree).2

Physician Assistant (PA): PAs have extensive medical training to diagnose illness, develop and manage treatment plans, prescribe medications, perform procedures, and serve as a patient’s primary healthcare provider. Most PAs have a four-year undergraduate degree and an additional two to three years of postgraduate education. They often work on a team of physicians and have a degree of independence in their practice. They can meet with patients independently but must always consult with a physician regarding patient care including treatment plans, prescribing, and when performing procedures.1

Advanced Practice Registered Nurse (APRN): An APRN is a registered nurse with additional education, training, and certification. They obtain a Master of Science or doctoral degree as well as advanced clinical training and a specialty certification. As a registered nurse, an APRN can perform any of an RN’s roles and (depending on the state) some roles more traditionally reserved for MDs or DOs, such as diagnosing and treating patients, prescribing medication, and serving as a patient’s main healthcare provider. The full scope of practice for the various APRNs depends on state licensing regulations. For example, some states require the supervision of a physician to prescribe medication, while in other states they can prescribe medication and practice independently.1

The four APRN specialties are:3

  • Certified Nurse Practitioner (CNP)
  • Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist (CRNA)
  • Clinical Nurse Specialist (CNS)
  • Certified Nurse Midwife (CNM)

General Nursing Licenses

Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN) and Licensed Vocational Nurse (LVN): LPN and LVN are interchangeable as to their roles but have different titles based on state regulations. Both have the same level of education—about a year of nursing education—and generally perform less technical skills than do registered nurses or APPs, including tasks like taking vitals and observing patients under the supervision of a registered nurse or physician.1,3

Registered Nurse (RN): An RN obtains a four-year nursing degree and has passed a licensing exam. They can provide direct patient care in inpatient and outpatient settings and are often in charge of monitoring patients, taking vital signs, administering medications, and documenting patient history.1

Other Disciplines

Doctor of Dental Surgery (DDS) vs. Doctor of Dental Medicine (DMD): DDS and DMD are equivalent degrees. Dental schools determine which degree is awarded, but both degrees use the same curriculum requirements and perform the same range of services. Education levels required to become a DDS or DMD include three or more years of undergraduate education and four years of dental school.4

Doctor of Podiatric Medicine (DPM): Podiatric doctors focus on examining, diagnosing, and treating issues that affect the lower extremities. They can perform surgery and prescribe medication and medical devices. A podiatrist’s education and training require a doctoral degree and residency. Some also choose additional fellowship training.5

Doctor of Chiropractic (DC): Doctors of chiropractic treat the neuromusculoskeletal system and focus on the body’s ability to self-heal. They study similar subjects, earn a doctoral degree, pass a board exam, and obtain a license to practice. Doctoral programs include supervised hands-on experience.6

References

1. “MD, DO, PA, NP, MA and More: What Do These Letters Mean?” Banner Health, https://www.bannerhealth.com/healthcareblog/teach-me/md-do-pa-np-ma-and-more-what-these-letters-mean
2. “Difference Between Advanced-Practice Providers and Physicians” ProspectiveDoctor, https://www.prospectivedoctor.com/difference-between-advanced-practice-providers-and-physicians/
3. “Levels of Nursing & Ranks Explained,” Nurse.org, https://nurse.org/education/nursing-hierarchy-guide/
4. “What Are the Difference Between DDS and DMD?” MouthHealthy, https://www.mouthhealthy.org/all-topics-a-z/dds-and-dmd
5. “Podiatrist,” Cleveland Clinic, https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/articles/podiatrist
6. “Chiropractor,” WebMD, https://www.webmd.com/a-to-z-guides/chiropractor

ScottSpinolawTITLEupdate

 

Important Business Development Leadership Changes

Effective November 17, 2026, Kendra Heredia will lead the combined ProAssurance and The Doctors Company MPL Business Development teams as head of Business Development. As we enter 2027, we’re bringing our teams together as one, with closer alignment with Underwriting. That means continuity, faster decisions, and clear points of contact for you.

Mike Rosenthal is no longer with the company. We thank him for his contributions and appreciate the relationships he built with many of you.

We are committed to a smooth transition, including careful handoff of any open items. If you have questions, please reach out to Deepika Srivastava, Chief Operating Officer
The Doctors Company, Kendra, or your Business Development contact. 

NewsUpdates_TDC
AMA Says AI Can’t Be Licensed as a Physician, Pushes Vendor Liability

The AMA House of Delegates approved the policy Nov. 9 at its Interim Meeting in Orlando, Fla. It calls for AI-enabled tools to be integrated into physician-led teams and used at the direction of the treating physician. AI used for clinical functions such as diagnosis, prescribing and care management should have transparent, auditable evidence of safety and efficacy and be subject to regulation, documentation and liability requirements. (Becker’s Hospital Review)  

Read more →

NAIC Report Finds Cyber Insurance Market Has Nearly Tripled Since 2020 as Cyber Risk Grows

As cybersecurity risks continue to increase and evolve, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ (NAIC) report for the 2025 calendar year finds that the cyber insurance market is growing alongside them. Total U.S. domestic cyber direct written business has nearly tripled since 2020, making cyber insurance one of the fastest-expanding segments in insurance. (NAIC)  

Read more →

Doctor Performs Surgery on Patient at Hospital 35 Miles Away Using Robotics

Dr. Vipul Patel, founder and medical director of the Global Robotics Institute at AdventHealth Celebration in Celebration, Florida, near Orlando, used the robotic system to perform surgery on a 66-year-old man with prostate cancer. (ABC News)  

Read more →

U.S. Property and Casualty Insurance Industry Investment Trends

The US property and casualty (P&C) insurance industry is coming off its best underwriting result in 20 years, leaving it with bolstered capital and enhanced balance sheet flexibility (source: S&P Global, 2026). This position of strength creates greater capacity for the industry to consider return-enhancing investments. And while the industry’s exposure to risk assets appears elevated on an unadjusted basis, Chart 1 is meaningfully lower after excluding affiliated holdings and two large outlier companies, suggesting many insurers have room to take on additional investment risk. (MPL Association)  

Read more →

6 Drug-Resistant Pathogens Hospitals Worry About Most

The CDC’s 2026 “Antimicrobial Resistance Threats Report” estimates the impact of 19 drug-resistant bacterial and fungal pathogens on human health in the U.S. They are categorized into three threat levels. Urgent threats require urgent and aggressive action. Serious threats require prompt and sustained action, and concerning threats require careful monitoring and prevention action, the report said. The CDC also included a watch list of pathogens being monitored because their full burden is not yet understood. (Becker’s Hospital Review)  

Read more →

The 20 Most Expensive Conditions Hospitals Treat: Report

The report, published February 2026, used 2022 data from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality’s Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project on hospital costs of inpatient stays in nonfederal acute care hospitals. Using the 2022 HCUP National Inpatient Sample, the report found the distribution of costs by primary expected payer and the conditions that accounted for the largest percentage of payer’s hospital costs. Hospital charges were converted to costs using HCUP cost-to-charge ratios. Payers included Medicare, Medicaid, private insurance and self-pay/no charge. (Becker’s Hospital Review)  

Read more →

RMUpdates_TDC

Risk Management Updates

Rapid Risk Review

Telehealth: Risks and Insights from the Front Lines

Telehealth has transformed medical care, bringing new opportunities and unique challenges. In this episode of the Rapid Risk Review Podcast, Dr. Brian Carpenter, Chief Medical Officer at Sound Physicians, joins us to explore the intricacies of telehealth and its implications for patient safety and risk management. 

LISTEN IN

Keep Up-to-Date on All Our Risk Management Resources

Our weekly risk management newsletter features the latest releases from ProAssurance’s Risk Management department—as well as highlights from our expansive online library of tools and publications. Join our email list.

ProVisions Team

Emily Kelly-Gillingham
Emily Kelly-Gillingham Communications & Digital Marketing Director
Headshot_KristenProVWeb
Kristen Hensley Communications Supervisor
ScottSpinola
Scott Spinola Senior Communications Coordinator
Kaelin O'Reilly
Kaelin O'Reilly Senior Communications Specialist
EricaHess 1
Erica Hess Manager, Creative Services
Kat McPeak
Kat McPeak Senior Creative Services Coordinator
ErikSeelman 1
Erik Seelman Senior Graphic Design Specialist
AndrewSegura
Andrew Segura Digital Marketing Supervisor
BethUlle
Bethany Ulle Senior Digital Marketing Specialist
Nov26ProV_Footer